Skip to main content
Serving Buyers & Sellers in Columbia County, NY

1 Lewis Lane, New Paltz, NY 12561 (MLS# 20264811)


$690,000
1 Lewis Lane
New Paltz, NY 12561
MLS# 20264811
7 baths  |  4100 sqft


DBA6C7A5-45A8-416E-A95F-2C6D845A886A_1_2
  1 / 32  
DBA6C7A5-45A8-416E-A95F-2C6D845A886A_1_2 06B391AC-35A1-47F9-8A8F-F9177E85E867_1_2 247BAF70-056B-42C8-AB1D-1A64FE30929F_1_2 D30EB4F0-582B-4967-944D-4951B94027CB_1_2 77C0DBB5-EF70-489F-BF18-8EAC9BE85EAC 7D8D31E9-4C5C-45D4-BCAA-8BA4C65F7400_1_2 E35EE84D-ABC0-46C4-B104-4426951711B0_1_2 88096F30-E0EF-4ACB-B709-FBC19764729D_1_2 F4939763-231E-4A18-91BB-4E63309FDECE_1_2 1D4434A0-3424-4641-A906-D4B7D66B1450 C5A2AFC7-380D-4F75-8735-1698046F8000_1_2 A4115AD9-606C-49F6-ABDE-F1D7CB64C2E0_1_2 0D1A31F4-A11F-475A-B6BC-BF4496976464_1_2 2B1D7A86-4A4C-4759-BE94-72FAD2764711_1_2 CDE281D1-B7C1-446D-BBD4-E90B1A71BB4C_1_2 E6528E0E-8733-40EA-B879-EA69B481B58F_1_2 88CF8DCC-3152-4F5F-B872-8961E91C721D_1_2 1BA2DA59-7967-461B-BE55-81FB9452AAA4_1_2 B61BAD39-AFF4-4640-A7B5-AA62863DA39B_1_2 8BD25D08-88F0-4A60-BEE3-B39AE62F4B7A_1_2 B4606EE2-0F98-4122-B710-2535F8AF2F16_1_2 80A0E64C-C1FB-4435-B981-CAD498204DD3 1D4434A0-3424-4641-A906-D4B7D66B1450_1_2 42430504-2CD2-464F-8E1F-9879612ECDB9_1_2 DAC42E86-6029-4644-9C23-212D8E78307E_1_2 56BFF093-7B85-4DD9-877B-B2DA0B426F5E_1_2 06DBDE95-1556-4135-A351-0300DAEE10BA_1_2 42892A67-F29B-43CF-A874-B3E15EEC8743_1_2 DBA6C7A5-45A8-416E-A95F-2C6D845A886A_1_2 80226383-B27E-4620-84C6-98C9C6B3CDD5_1_2 91FE0C73-FC3A-4351-8FBB-2031DD28437D_1_2 CBE621F0-638A-4F49-B004-BDD5989D32A8_1_2

Property Description
Rarely available, this established six-unit multifamily property offers an exceptional opportunity to acquire an income-producing asset on 12.9 private, pastoral acres just outside the Village of New Paltz. Combining stable rental income, long-term tenancy, and meaningful value-added potential, the property is ideally positioned in one of the Hudson Valley's most desirable and consistently strong rental markets. The building comprises six apartments distributed across the first, second, and third floors: two studios, two one-bedroom units, one two-bedroom unit, and one three-bedroom unit. A walkout lower level provides valuable additional amenities, including tenant storage, a dedicated laundry facility, and a spacious owner's office suite--an attractive feature for an owner-operator or investor seeking functional on-site workspace. The property's generous acreage provides an uncommon sense of privacy and open space for a multifamily property. Sun-filled grounds offer residents opportunities for raised-bed flower and vegetable gardening, adding to the property's appeal and creating a distinctive community-oriented living environment. Each apartment is separately metered for electricity, with electric service billed directly to tenants. The landlord is responsible for common-area maintenance and other utilities. The property benefits from a stable base of long-term tenants, providing an established income stream while leaving potential for future enhancement and increased value. The location is equally compelling. Set just outside the Village of New Paltz, the property is part of a vibrant college town where the Hudson River Valley meets the dramatic Shawangunk Mountain Ridge. Residents enjoy an extraordinary combination of natural beauty and cultural amenities, with world-class hiking, biking, swimming and rock climbing complemented by exceptional arts, culture, dining and entertainment. A compelling opportunity to acquire a well-established multifamily property with scale, acreage, stable tenancy, and upside potential in one of the Hudson Valley's most sought-after communities.

Details
Contract Information
Current Price: $690,000
Original List Price: 850000
List Price: $690,000
Status: Active
Listing Contract Date: 2026-08-20
Property Sub Type: Other
Listing Agreement: Exclusive Agency
Owner Name: Estate of Gregory T. Stengel
Lease Considered YN: No
General Property Information
Number Of Units Total: 6
Bathrooms Total: 7
Living Area: 4100
Year Built: 1965
Lot Size Acres: 12.9
Flood Plain YN: Yes
Frontage Length: 460 Feet
Sign On Property YN: No
Disclaimer: Buyer agent to confirm all listing info. Square footage per Ulster County record.
Rent Control YN: No
List Price/SqFt: 168.29
Remarks and Miscellaneous
Public Remarks: Rarely available, this established six-unit multifamily property offers an exceptional opportunity to acquire an income-producing asset on 12.9 private, pastoral acres just outside the Village of New Paltz. Combining stable rental income, long-term tenancy, and meaningful value-added potential, the property is ideally positioned in one of the Hudson Valley's most desirable and consistently strong rental markets. The building comprises six apartments distributed across the first, second, and third floors: two studios, two one-bedroom units, one two-bedroom unit, and one three-bedroom unit. A walkout lower level provides valuable additional amenities, including tenant storage, a dedicated laundry facility, and a spacious owner's office suite--an attractive feature for an owner-operator or investor seeking functional on-site workspace. The property's generous acreage provides an uncommon sense of privacy and open space for a multifamily property. Sun-filled grounds offer residents opportunities for raised-bed flower and vegetable gardening, adding to the property's appeal and creating a distinctive community-oriented living environment. Each apartment is separately metered for electricity, with electric service billed directly to tenants. The landlord is responsible for common-area maintenance and other utilities. The property benefits from a stable base of long-term tenants, providing an established income stream while leaving potential for future enhancement and increased value. The location is equally compelling. Set just outside the Village of New Paltz, the property is part of a vibrant college town where the Hudson River Valley meets the dramatic Shawangunk Mountain Ridge. Residents enjoy an extraordinary combination of natural beauty and cultural amenities, with world-class hiking, biking, swimming and rock climbing complemented by exceptional arts, culture, dining and entertainment. A compelling opportunity to acquire a well-established multifamily property with scale, acreage, stable tenancy, and upside potential in one of the Hudson Valley's most sought-after communities.
Status Change Information
Major Change Timestamp: 2026-11-04T03:17:01Z
Major Change Type: Price Reduced
Price Change Timestamp: 2026-11-04T03:17:01Z
Status Change Timestamp: 2026-08-20
Book Information
Liber/Book: 01911
Page: 00228
Section: 86.1
Income and Expenses
Financials Available Y/N: Yes
Showing Information
Showing Attended YN: Yes
Location Tax and Legal
Street Number: 1
Street Name: Lewis
Street Suffix: Lane
County: Ulster
State: NY
Zip Code: 12561
Town (Taxable): New Paltz
Property Features
Appliances: Electric Cooktop; Electric Oven; Electric Water Heater; Range; Refrigerator; Washer/Dryer
Business Type: Residential
Construction Materials: Frame
Cooling: Varies by Unit
Current Use: Multi-Family; Residential
Electric: 200+ Amp Service
Exterior Features: Garden
Flooring: Combination; Hardwood; Tile; Varies
Heating: Oil; Zoned
Location: Rural
Lot Features: Garden; Private; Secluded; Sloped; Subdivide Possible
Owner Pays: Common Area Maintenance; Insurance; Oil; Pest Control; Snow Removal; Trash Collection
Roof: Asphalt
Sewer: Private Sewer
Showing Considerations: Occupied; See Remarks
Structure Type: Multi Family
Tenant Pays: Electricity
Water Source: Well
Showing Requirements: Appointment Only; Call Listing Agent; Listing Agent Must Accompany; No Sign
Sale Includes: Building; Land

Listing Courtesy of Halter Associates Realty
Listing Agent: Peter Cantine

Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.