1781 New York 23, Craryville, NY 12521 (MLS# 20264516)
$795,000
Craryville, NY 12521
MLS# 20264516
3 beds | 3 baths | 2816 sqft
1 / 40
Property Description
A truly distinctive Hudson Valley property, 1781 State Route 23 pairs a charming 1930 Arts and Crafts-style parsonage with the fully historic former Craryville United Methodist Church. Both buildings have been renovated with new kitchens, baths and heating and cooling. The parsonage residence offers approximately 1,458 square feet, split into two 1 bedroom apartments. While the separate church building features roughly 1,358 square feet, soaring ceilings, a full bath, a full kitchen, and a lower-level work and shop space. Set on approximately .8 acre between Hudson and Great Barrington, this one-of-a-kind property presents exciting possibilities for residential, creative, commercial, live/work, or gathering-space use--subject to applicable approvals. Rich in character and local history, it's ready for its next inspired chapter.
Details
Documents
Contract Information
Accessory Dwelling Unit YN: Yes
Listing Agreement: Exclusive Right To Sell
Owner Name: Potata Puff LLC
Occupant Type: Owner
Lease Considered YN: No
Current Price: $795,000
Original List Price: 695000
List Price: $795,000
Status: Active
Listing Contract Date: 2026-08-06
Property Sub Type: Single Family Residence
Location, Tax, and Legal
911 Address: 1781 State Route 23
Township: Craryville
School District: Taconic Hills Central Schools
General Tax: 3705
School Tax: 4207
Tax Annual Amount: 7912
Assessors Full Market Value: 430677
Tax Assessed Value: 258400
Tax Legal Description: 144.4-1-7.3
Parcel Number: 144.4-1-7.3
Tax Lot: 144
Tax Block: 4-1-7
Tax Exemptions YN: No
Zoning: HB
Zoning Description: Hamlet Business
Directions: From Route 22 west on Route 23 to # 1781 on right see sign
General Property Information
Rooms Total: 6
Bathrooms Half: 0
Above Grade Finished Area: 2816
Below Grade Finished Area: 2087
Lot Size Acres: 0.807
Association YN: No
Accessibility Features YN: No
New Construction YN: No
Garage YN: Yes
Attached Garage YN: No
Garage Spaces: 1
Waterfront YN: No
Flood Plain YN: Unknown
Senior Community YN: No
Sign On Property YN: Yes
Basement YN: Yes
Stories: 2
Fireplace YN: No
Wood Stove YN: No
Spa YN: No
List Price/SqFt: 282.32
Bedrooms Total: 3
Bathrooms Total: 3
Bathrooms Full: 3
Living Area: 2816
Year Built: 1923
Remarks and Miscellaneous
Public Remarks: A truly distinctive Hudson Valley property, 1781 State Route 23 pairs a charming 1930 Arts and Crafts-style parsonage with the fully historic former Craryville United Methodist Church. Both buildings have been renovated with new kitchens, baths and heating and cooling. The parsonage residence offers approximately 1,458 square feet, split into two 1 bedroom apartments. While the separate church building features roughly 1,358 square feet, soaring ceilings, a full bath, a full kitchen, and a lower-level work and shop space. Set on approximately .8 acre between Hudson and Great Barrington, this one-of-a-kind property presents exciting possibilities for residential, creative, commercial, live/work, or gathering-space use--subject to applicable approvals. Rich in character and local history, it's ready for its next inspired chapter.
Status Change Information
Status Change Timestamp: 2026-08-07
Major Change Timestamp: 2026-08-08T13:30:14Z
Major Change Type: Price Change
Price Change Timestamp: 2026-08-08T13:30:14Z
Accessory Dwelling Unit Information
ADU Bathrooms: 2
ADU Bedrooms: 2
ADU Building Type: Stand-Alone
ADU SqFt: 1358
Architectural Style
Arts & Crafts: 1
Basement
Finished: 1
Full: 1
Storage Space: 1
Book Information
Liber/Book: 999
Page: 1043
Section: 1
Location Tax and Legal
Street Number: 1781
Street Name: New York 23
County: Columbia
State: NY
Zip Code: 12521
Town (Taxable): Copake
Property Features
Architectural Style: Arts & Crafts
Basement: Finished; Full; Storage Space
Survey 
Listing Courtesy of Elyse Harney Real Estate
Listing Agent: John Panzer