Skip to main content
Serving Buyers & Sellers in Columbia County, NY

2666 New York 23, Hillsdale, NY 12529 (MLS# 20262449)


$1,100,000
2666 New York 23
Hillsdale, NY 12529
MLS# 20262449
3 beds  |  4 baths  |  2880 sqft


2666 Rte 23 Hillsdale. Fondly known as the Althouse-Higgins
  1 / 54  
2666 Rte 23 Hillsdale. Fondly known as the Althouse-Higgins 3 Units / 2 Retail spaces 1st floor. Fully furnished lucrative AirBnB 2nd floor 2666 State Rte 23, Hillsdale NY 3 Units / 2 Retail spaces 1st floor. Fully furnished lucrative AirBnB 2nd floor 3 Units / 2 Retail spaces 1st floor. Fully furnished lucrative AirBnB 2nd floor 1 2 2nd flr of left side, currently used as Office for Peckham Industries, Inc. 2nd flr of left side, currently used as Office for Peckham Industries, Inc. 1st flr of left side, currently used as Office for Peckham Industries, Inc. 1st flr of left side, currently used as Office for Peckham Industries, Inc. 1st flr of right side, currently used as Antique shop 1st flr of right side, currently used as Antique shop Lucrative AirBnB 2nd floor of main building Lucrative AirBnB 2nd floor of main building Lucrative AirBnB 2nd floor of main building Lucrative AirBnB 2nd floor of main building Lucrative AirBnB 2nd floor of main building Lucrative AirBnB 2nd floor of main building Lucrative AirBnB 2nd floor of main building Lucrative AirBnB 2nd floor of main building Lucrative AirBnB 2nd floor of main building Shared back deck for 2 Retail Shops Shared back deck for 2 Retail Shops Shared back deck for 2 Retail Shops Main Street Hillsdale Rte 23 Main Street Hillsdale Rte 23 Circa 1845 Carriage house residence Circa 1845 Carriage house residence Circa 1845 Carriage house residence 7Y3A8679 DJI_0438 Circa 1845 Carriage house residence Circa 1845 Carriage house residence Circa 1845 Carriage house residence Circa 1845 Carriage house residence Circa 1845 Carriage house residence Circa 1845 Carriage house residence Circa 1845 Carriage house residence Circa 1845 Carriage house residence 2nd_floor_2666_state_highway_23_red_barn 2nd_floor_2666_state_highway_23_rental_1 all_floors_2666_state_highway_23_overnig all_floors_2666_state_highway_23_rental_ all_floors_2666_state_highway_23_rental_ all_floors_2666_state_highway_23_red_bar 1st_floor_2666_state_highway_23_overnigh 1st_floor_2666_state_highway_23_red_barn 1st_floor_2666_state_highway_23_rental_1 2nd_floor_2666_state_highway_23_overnigh DJI_0478 DJI_0483 DJI_0418 DJI_0498

Property Description
Unique investment opportunity in the hamlet of Hillsdale. This new-to-the-market commercial/residential property has been meticulously renovated by the current owner, a commercial builder, who over-engineered the project with high-end features throughout. The property consists of four distinct rental units: 2666 Route 23, Main (Blue) Building - First-Floor Commercial Unit Right Side: 360 sq. ft. (currently Antique Shop) - Second-Floor Residential Apartment: Two bedrooms, 737 sq. ft. (currently VERY LUCRATIVE AirBnB) - Two-Story Commercial Unit Left Side: 766 sq. ft. (currently leased 12+/- mo. to State) Red Barn Building - Two-Story Barn Renovation: Two bedrooms, one bath, 791 sq. ft. (currently VERY LUCRATIVE AirBnB) Main Building: Circa 1880 3 Units ~ 2 Commercial Retails and a Fully Furnished turn key AirBnB/Apartment In the Berkshire/Taconic Mtn area, main building was fully renovated creating retail shops and a sophisticated but casually comfortable 2 BR apt. saving many of the original building features. Efficiency kitchen (convention microwave, cooktop, Mr. Coffee, all utensils, cookware, DW) with a W/D, marble bath, sleeps 4 , cable TV and internet. Bright and airy, full AC. Children friendly with tamper proof outlets, central station fire alarm system, CO detector. Offered Fully Furnished. The Carriage House ~ Private Residence AirBnB This structure was built around 1845 as a carriage house for the main building. The building's structure was completely reconstructed with great sensitivity to the unique features of the original use. The hay loft floor remains as a ceiling for the 1st floor although it is now 11 ft high. The 1st floor consists of an open plan living space with a washer/dryer combo tucked tastefully in the utility space. The 2nd floor has 2 bedrooms and a bathroom highlighted by the exposed timber roof framing. The space; the effort to maintain the 1845 appeal of the space is very successful with finishes utilizing reclaimed materials from the main house renovation as well as much from the original carriage house. The original siding has been incorporated into the interior walls abutting the timber framed structure. The bathroom is finished with Carrera marble tile shower walls and floor. Five panel mahogany doors complete the charming ambiance of the space. The Barn is highly energy efficient with spray foam insulation, new Pella windows and heat pump supplying environmental comfort. Immediately outside the entrance is a blue-stone paver patio with dining table chairs, Adirondack seating and gas grill. This overlooks a calming view of gardens and neighboring backyards. Offered Fully Furnished. Five Start AirBnB stats upon request. Purchased in 2012, transformed into sophisticated retail/residential, vacation getaway spaces, while preserving many original architectural features - see list of improvements. Basement of main building could easily be converted into additional living space. Features include high ceilings, water already hooked up etc. The location is ideal for a four-season destination, situated near Catamount Ski and Adventure Park, the Copake-Hillsdale Farmers Market, the Harlem Valley Rail Trail (goes all the way to NYC now!), and Taghkanic State Park. It also offers easy access to the dining and entertainment options in Hudson and the Berkshires. This is an exceptional multi-use property for anyone seeking a high-quality investment in Columbia County.

Details
Contract Information
Current Price: $1,100,000
Original List Price: 1100000
List Price: $1,100,000
Status: Active
Listing Contract Date: 2026-05-15
Property Sub Type: Quadruplex
Listing Agreement: Exclusive Right To Sell
Owner Name: Sullivan
Lease Considered YN: No
General Property Information
Number Of Units Total: 4
Bedrooms Total: 3
Bathrooms Total: 4
Above Grade Finished Area: 2880
Below Grade Finished Area: 2880
Living Area: 2880
New Construction YN: No
Year Built: 1880
Lot Size Acres: 0.5
Flood Plain YN: No
Association YN: No
Basement YN: Yes
Stories: 2
Units Furnished: Varies By Unit
Fireplace YN: No
Wood Stove YN: No
Spa YN: No
Sign On Property YN: Yes
List Price/SqFt: 381.94
Remarks and Miscellaneous
Public Remarks: Unique investment opportunity in the hamlet of Hillsdale. This new-to-the-market commercial/residential property has been meticulously renovated by the current owner, a commercial builder, who over-engineered the project with high-end features throughout. The property consists of four distinct rental units: 2666 Route 23, Main (Blue) Building - First-Floor Commercial Unit Right Side: 360 sq. ft. (currently Antique Shop) - Second-Floor Residential Apartment: Two bedrooms, 737 sq. ft. (currently VERY LUCRATIVE AirBnB) - Two-Story Commercial Unit Left Side: 766 sq. ft. (currently leased 12+/- mo. to State) Red Barn Building - Two-Story Barn Renovation: Two bedrooms, one bath, 791 sq. ft. (currently VERY LUCRATIVE AirBnB) Main Building: Circa 1880 3 Units ~ 2 Commercial Retails and a Fully Furnished turn key AirBnB/Apartment In the Berkshire/Taconic Mtn area, main building was fully renovated creating retail shops and a sophisticated but casually comfortable 2 BR apt. saving many of the original building features. Efficiency kitchen (convention microwave, cooktop, Mr. Coffee, all utensils, cookware, DW) with a W/D, marble bath, sleeps 4 , cable TV and internet. Bright and airy, full AC. Children friendly with tamper proof outlets, central station fire alarm system, CO detector. Offered Fully Furnished. The Carriage House ~ Private Residence AirBnB This structure was built around 1845 as a carriage house for the main building. The building's structure was completely reconstructed with great sensitivity to the unique features of the original use. The hay loft floor remains as a ceiling for the 1st floor although it is now 11 ft high. The 1st floor consists of an open plan living space with a washer/dryer combo tucked tastefully in the utility space. The 2nd floor has 2 bedrooms and a bathroom highlighted by the exposed timber roof framing. The space; the effort to maintain the 1845 appeal of the space is very successful with finishes utilizing reclaimed materials from the main house renovation as well as much from the original carriage house. The original siding has been incorporated into the interior walls abutting the timber framed structure. The bathroom is finished with Carrera marble tile shower walls and floor. Five panel mahogany doors complete the charming ambiance of the space. The Barn is highly energy efficient with spray foam insulation, new Pella windows and heat pump supplying environmental comfort. Immediately outside the entrance is a blue-stone paver patio with dining table chairs, Adirondack seating and gas grill. This overlooks a calming view of gardens and neighboring backyards. Offered Fully Furnished. Five Start AirBnB stats upon request. Purchased in 2012, transformed into sophisticated retail/residential, vacation getaway spaces, while preserving many original architectural features - see list of improvements. Basement of main building could easily be converted into additional living space. Features include high ceilings, water already hooked up etc. The location is ideal for a four-season destination, situated near Catamount Ski and Adventure Park, the Copake-Hillsdale Farmers Market, the Harlem Valley Rail Trail (goes all the way to NYC now!), and Taghkanic State Park. It also offers easy access to the dining and entertainment options in Hudson and the Berkshires. This is an exceptional multi-use property for anyone seeking a high-quality investment in Columbia County.
Status Change Information
Major Change Timestamp: 2026-05-16T02:57:37Z
Major Change Type: New Listing
Status Change Timestamp: 2026-05-15
Book Information
Liber/Book: Deed
Page: 360
Section: 145
Income and Expenses
Financials Available Y/N: Yes
Electric Expense: 5000
Gross Income: 50000
Gross Scheduled Income: 50000
Insurance Expense: 3500
Maintenance Expense: 1500
Other Income: 4
Sewer Expense: 2700
Total Actual Rent: 30600
Unit 1 Information
Actual Rent: 975
Baths Partial: 1
Leased YN: Yes
Unit Lease Terms: 12 Months
Occupied YN: Yes
Unit Description: Antique Shop/Retail
Unit 2 Information
Actual Rent: 1500
Baths Total: 1
Leased YN: Yes
Unit Lease Terms: 12 Months
Occupied YN: Yes
Unit Description: Peckham Industries Field Office
Unit 3 Information
Actual Rent: 240
Baths Full: 1
Baths Total: 1
Beds Total: 2
Unit Lease Terms: Weekly
Unit Description: Althouse 2nd Fl. Apt. AirBnB $240/night
Unit 4 Information
Actual Rent: 260
Baths Full: 1
Baths Total: 1
Beds Total: 2
Unit Lease Terms: Weekly
Unit Description: The Barn
Showing Information
Showing Attended YN: Yes
Historical Information
SqFt 1st (Legacy): 2880
Location Tax and Legal
Street Number: 2666
Street Name: New York 23
County: Columbia
State: NY
Zip Code: 12529
Town (Taxable): Hillsdale
Property Features
Appliances: Dishwasher; Microwave; Range; Refrigerator; Washer/Dryer
Architectural Style: Carriage House; Cottage; Farmhouse; Gothic Revival
Attic Features: Unfinished
Basement: Apartment; Full; Walk-Out Access; Walk-Up Access
Community Features: Clubhouse; Fishing; Golf; Lake; Park; Playground; Racquetball; Restaurant; Sidewalks; Storm Drains; Street Lights
Construction Materials: Frame
Electric: 220 Volts in Kitchen
Exterior Features: Balcony; Courtyard; Private Entrance; Private Yard; Rain Gutters
Fencing: Back Yard
Flooring: Ceramic Tile; Combination; Concrete; Hardwood; Varies; Wood
Foundation Details: Block; Brick/Mortar
Green Energy Efficient: Insulation
Heating: Baseboard; Electric; Varies by Unit
Interior Features: Cathedral Ceiling(s); Ceiling Fan(s); Eat-in Kitchen; High Speed Internet; Kitchen Island; Pantry; Walk-In Closet(s)
Laundry Features: In Basement
Levels: Bi-Level
Listing Terms: Contract
Lot Features: Few Trees; Front Yard; Near Golf Course; Paved; Rectangular Lot; Views
Other Equipment: Varies by Unit
Other Structures: Guest House; Residence; Second Residence; Workshop
Owner Pays: All Utilities
Parking Features: Driveway; Private
Patio And Porch Features: Deck; Patio; Porch
Possession: Close Of Escrow
Property Condition: Updated/Remodeled
Road Frontage Type: Town
Road Surface Type: Paved
Roof: Shingle
Security Features: Carbon Monoxide Detector(s); Smoke Detector(s)
Sewer: Public Sewer
Structure Type: Hotel/Motel; Mixed Use; Multi Family; Retail
Unit 3 Information: Kitchen; Living Room
Unit 4 Information: Dining Room; Living Room
Utilities: Electricity Available; Sewer Available; Water Connected
View: Mountain(s); Neighborhood
Water Source: Well
Window Features: Other
Showing Requirements: Call Listing Agent; Text Listing Agent

Listing Courtesy of Columbia County RE Specialist
Listing Agent: Margaret Bower Avenia

Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.